
The Hoxton, Chicago
Best for travelers who want a trendy Fulton Market base, rooftop pool seasonally, and an active dining/nightlife scene.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Hoxton, Chicago is a 4-star Fulton Market boutique hotel with a seasonal rooftop pool and a social dining scene; read this if you want a lively West Loop stay close to restaurants and nightlife. The Peninsula Chicago is a landmark five-star hotel on the Magnificent Mile known for polished service, a full-service spa and classic luxury; read this if you prefer Magnificent Mile access and traditional five-star amenities.
Updated · about 2.5 km apart

Best for travelers who want a trendy Fulton Market base, rooftop pool seasonally, and an active dining/nightlife scene.

Best for travelers who want classic five-star service, a full-service spa and a central Magnificent Mile location.
When The Hoxton, Chicago wins: choose The Hoxton for a smaller, buzzy Fulton Market experience with lively ground-floor and rooftop restaurants, a seasonal rooftop pool and a boutique, social atmosphere suited to younger travelers or groups who want to be near Restaurant Row and the West Loop scene.
When The Peninsula Chicago wins: pick The Peninsula for a traditional five-star Magnificent Mile stay, larger room inventory, an on-site full-service spa and an indoor pool, plus the kind of polished service and central Michigan Avenue access many visitors expect from a luxury landmark hotel.
Bottom line: both are luxury choices but very different styles—Hoxton is a boutique, social stay in Fulton Market with a seasonal rooftop pool; The Peninsula is a larger, classic five-star near Michigan Avenue with year-round spa and pool facilities. Choose based on whether neighborhood vibe or formal five-star amenities matter more to you.
| Category | The Hoxton, Chicago | The Peninsula Chicago |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, social, West Loop lifestyle hotel | Landmark five-star luxury hotel on the Magnificent Mile |
| Location | Fulton Market / West Loop (near Morgan CTA station) | Michigan Avenue / Magnificent Mile (near Water Tower) |
| Size | 182 guestrooms | 339 guestrooms |
| Ages | All ages welcome (family-friendly) | |
| Pools | One seasonal outdoor rooftop pool (12th floor) | One indoor pool (year-round) |
| Restaurants & bars | Cira (Mediterranean), Cabra (Peruvian rooftop), Lazy Bird bar, Milk Bar cafe | 2 restaurants (including Shanghai Terrace), 1 bar/lounge, room service |
| Spa & wellness | No traditional on-site spa listed; wellness/yoga studio and 24-hour fitness studio | Full-service spa with massages and body treatments; health club |
| Known for | Rooftop pool, chef-driven restaurants and a lively neighborhood scene | Classic luxury service, central Magnificent Mile address and a full-service spa |
| Check-in / Check-out | Check-in from 2:00 PM; check-out 12:00 PM | Check-in from 3:00 PM; check-out 12:00 PM |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly; pet amenities provided (per hotel sources) | Pets allowed in specific rooms only; pet fee applies |
The Hoxton sits in Fulton Market, a creative dining-and-gallery neighborhood.
Hoxton is best if you want to be in Fulton Market’s restaurant-and-nightlife hub.
The Peninsula is on Michigan Avenue, steps from shopping and downtown sights.
The Peninsula is better if you want direct Magnificent Mile access and classic downtown proximity.
The Hoxton offers 182 boutique-style guestrooms designed for a social urban stay.
Hoxton’s rooms are boutique-focused and suit guests wanting character and neighborhood energy.
The Peninsula offers 339 guestrooms with classic five-star finishes and premium bedding.
Peninsula’s larger room inventory and traditional room amenities suit travelers who want full-service luxury.
The Hoxton’s food and drink program centers on chef-driven concepts and a lively rooftop scene.
Hoxton emphasizes contemporary, local culinary footing and a social restaurant/bar scene.
The Peninsula has on-site dining options and room service in a formal five-star setting.
Peninsula is best if you want classic hotel dining with the convenience of on-site restaurants and room service.
The Hoxton’s signature seasonal rooftop pool is a focal point during warmer months.
Hoxton’s rooftop pool is a summer highlight and part of its social appeal, but it’s seasonal.
The Peninsula provides year-round pool access alongside a full-service spa.
Peninsula’s indoor pool and full-service spa are strong choices if you want wellness facilities year-round.
The Hoxton mixes a 24-hour fitness studio and local wellness options with an active nightlife program.
Hoxton is for guests who want an independent wellness offering and a lively evening scene.
The Peninsula focuses on traditional spa treatments and quieter, polished evening options.
Peninsula suits travelers who prioritize spa treatments and a refined, low-key evening ambiance.

The Hoxton — rooftop restaurant and pool, chef-driven ground-floor dining and a subterranean live-music bar.

The Peninsula — full-service spa plus an indoor pool and health club for cold-weather or all-season use.

The Peninsula — steps from Michigan Avenue shopping, Water Tower and classic downtown sights.

The Hoxton — Fulton Market location in a converted warehouse with neighborhood energy and smaller scale.
The Peninsula has an indoor pool available year-round. The Hoxton’s pool is a seasonal rooftop pool open roughly May–October.
Yes. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; The Hoxton explicitly allows children and offers family-friendly packages, and The Peninsula’s supplier listing notes it is family-friendly.
The Peninsula is on the Magnificent Mile. The Hoxton is in Fulton Market, roughly a 20–30 minute walk or a short drive from Michigan Avenue.
No. The Peninsula has a full-service spa; The Hoxton does not list a traditional on-site spa but offers a wellness/yoga studio and fitness facilities.
Explore how The Hoxton, Chicago stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·